Onyx Coffee Lab vs Heart Coffee Roasters
Onyx Coffee Lab and Heart Coffee Roasters are both Pacific light-roast specialists, but they operate at wildly different scales. Onyx offers 23 coffees with an average price of $64.86 per 100g, while Heart keeps a tight 5-coffee lineup averaging just $7.87 per 100g—a nearly 8x price gap that tells you almost everything about how differently they approach the market.
Last updated . Data refreshed daily from roaster webshops.
Onyx Coffee Lab
- Coffees tracked
- 60
- Avg price /100g
- US$25.25/100g
- Price range
- US$2.16/100g – US$188/100g
Heart Coffee Roasters
- Coffees tracked
- 5
- Avg price /100g
- US$8.69/100g
- Price range
- US$6.13/100g – US$17.45/100g
Top picks
Onyx Coffee Lab
Onyx is for coffee geeks chasing exotic processing methods and competition-grade microlots, especially from East Africa—they're the roaster you splurge on for a special bag.
Heart Coffee Roasters
Heart is for daily drinkers who want clean, approachable light roasts without the hype or the price tag—solid, dependable coffee you can afford to drink every morning.
Verdict
If you're brewing daily and want quality light roasts that won't drain your bank account, Heart is the obvious pick at $7.87 average per 100g. Onyx is the move when you want to taste what cutting-edge processing and competition-level coffee can do—just know you're paying $64+ per 100g for that education. For most people, Heart makes more sense as a subscription, Onyx as an occasional treat.
What they share
- Both built their reputations on modern light-roast profiles that highlight origin character over roast development
- Both source heavily from Colombia and maintain long-term producer relationships
- Both cater to the third-wave crowd that values transparency and origin storytelling
- Neither is afraid of natural and honey processing—Onyx's top sellers include multiple naturals and honeys
Key differences
- Price positioning: Onyx averages $64.86/100g with some bags reaching $259.65, while Heart tops out at $17.45/100g—Onyx is clearly targeting the ultra-premium collector market
- Portfolio depth: Onyx rotates 23 coffees with heavy East African focus (Rwanda, Burundi), while Heart keeps just 5 coffees and leans into Honduras and Ethiopia
- Accessibility: Heart's sub-$8 average makes them an everyday option; Onyx's prices put them firmly in special-occasion territory
- Sourcing style: Onyx chases rare microlots and competition coffees (Gabriel Castaño, Kanzu Station), while Heart appears to focus on repeatable, relationship-driven offerings (multiple Ramon Hernandez listings suggest a core stable)
Frequently asked questions
Is Onyx Coffee Lab or Heart Coffee Roasters better?
If you're brewing daily and want quality light roasts that won't drain your bank account, Heart is the obvious pick at $7.87 average per 100g. Onyx is the move when you want to taste what cutting-edge processing and competition-level coffee can do—just know you're paying $64+ per 100g for that education. For most people, Heart makes more sense as a subscription, Onyx as an occasional treat.
What is the price difference between Onyx Coffee Lab and Heart Coffee Roasters?
Onyx Coffee Lab averages $25.25/100g across 60 coffees. Heart Coffee Roasters averages $8.69/100g across 5 coffees.
Which is cheaper, Onyx Coffee Lab or Heart Coffee Roasters?
Heart Coffee Roasters averages lower per-100g pricing. Cheapest individual coffees: Onyx Coffee Lab from $2.16/100g, Heart Coffee Roasters from $6.13/100g.
Related comparisons
avant-garde light roast specialists
Onyx Coffee Lab vs SEY Coffeehigh-end specialty roasters
Onyx Coffee Lab vs Sweet Bloom Coffee Roasterspremium specialty roasters compared
Black & White Coffee Roasters vs Onyx Coffee Labmodern specialty roasters compared
Intelligentsia vs Onyx Coffee Labpioneer vs new wave specialty
Stumptown Coffee vs SEY Coffeeclassic third wave vs avant-garde