Stumptown Coffee vs Heart Coffee Roasters
Stumptown and Heart represent two chapters of Portland's specialty coffee story. Stumptown's current lineup focuses on just 2 blends averaging $11.32 per 100g, while Heart offers 5 coffees with heavy rotation from Ethiopia, Honduras, and Colombia at a lower $7.87 average. Both helped put Portland on the third-wave map, but they've evolved in different directions.
Last updated . Data refreshed daily from roaster webshops.
Stumptown Coffee
- Coffees tracked
- 18
- Avg price /100g
- US$7.95/100g
- Price range
- US$5.59/100g – US$21.48/100g
Heart Coffee Roasters
- Coffees tracked
- 5
- Avg price /100g
- US$8.69/100g
- Price range
- US$6.13/100g – US$17.45/100g
Top picks
Stumptown Coffee
Stumptown is for those who want a recognizable name and approachable blends—perfect if you're looking for consistency over exploration.
Heart Coffee Roasters
Heart is for origin-focused drinkers who want single-origin variety from specific producers like Ramon Hernandez, with better value on average.
Verdict
Go with Heart if you want single-origin variety and better value—$7.87 average gets you named-producer coffees with clear traceability. Pick Stumptown if you prefer the simplicity of dialed-in blends or you're buying for a crowd that wants something familiar. Heart wins for the explorer; Stumptown works for the streamlined home setup.
What they share
- Both are Portland institutions that helped define the city's coffee culture in the 2000s
- Both roast lighter to highlight origin character rather than dark roast tradition
- Both have price points that put them in the premium specialty coffee tier (both range up to $16-17 per 100g)
- Both maintain relationships with producers and emphasize traceability
Key differences
- Heart focuses heavily on single-origin offerings (top coffees all from Honduras producer Ramon Hernandez), while Stumptown's current selection is entirely blends
- Heart offers more selection (5 coffees vs 2) and better average value ($7.87 vs $11.32 per 100g)
- Heart sources primarily from Ethiopia, Honduras, and Colombia based on current offerings, while Stumptown's blend origins aren't specified in the data
- Stumptown has grown into a nationally distributed brand, while Heart has stayed more regionally focused
Frequently asked questions
Is Stumptown Coffee or Heart Coffee Roasters better?
Go with Heart if you want single-origin variety and better value—$7.87 average gets you named-producer coffees with clear traceability. Pick Stumptown if you prefer the simplicity of dialed-in blends or you're buying for a crowd that wants something familiar. Heart wins for the explorer; Stumptown works for the streamlined home setup.
What is the price difference between Stumptown Coffee and Heart Coffee Roasters?
Stumptown Coffee averages $7.95/100g across 18 coffees. Heart Coffee Roasters averages $8.69/100g across 5 coffees.
Which is cheaper, Stumptown Coffee or Heart Coffee Roasters?
Stumptown Coffee averages lower per-100g pricing. Cheapest individual coffees: Stumptown Coffee from $5.59/100g, Heart Coffee Roasters from $6.13/100g.
Related comparisons
Bay Area specialty roasters compared
Blue Bottle Coffee vs Ritual Coffee RoastersSan Francisco specialty pioneers
Andytown Coffee Roasters vs Saint Frank CoffeeSan Francisco specialty roasters
Sightglass Coffee vs Ritual Coffee RoastersSF design-forward specialty roasters
Wrecking Ball Coffee Roasters vs Sightglass CoffeeSan Francisco roasters compared
Bird Rock vs Cat & Cloud CoffeeSouthern California specialty compared